Choosing the Best Lead and Harness for Your Dog: A Friendly Guide
Walking our dogs is one of life’s simplest joys. Still, it can come with challenges—especially in urban environments where open spaces are limited and restrictions in parks, beaches, or public areas are increasing. While letting dogs run free is undeniably the most natural way for them to exercise, it’s not always possible or safe. Whether navigating a busy city or managing a dog still working on recall, having the right lead and harness can make all the difference.
With so many options available, it’s worth exploring the pros and cons of each type of lead and harness to find what best suits you and your dog. Let’s consider the options to ensure every walk is comfortable, safe, and enjoyable.
Types of Leads
When it comes to leads, there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. Each type of lead offers unique benefits and considerations depending on your dog’s size, temperament, and walking environment.
Nylon Leads
Nylon leads are a popular and budget-friendly choice for many dog owners. They’re lightweight, come in various colours and lengths, and are easy to clean—making them perfect for dogs that love muddy adventures. You can throw them in the wash to keep them fresh. However, nylon leads can sometimes feel slippery in your hands, especially if your dog is a puller, so they might not provide the best grip.
Leather Leads
Leather leads are a premium option known for their durability and classic appearance. If well-maintained, a leather lead can last a lifetime. However, they require regular care, as water exposure can cause leather to split or harden over time. Special leather conditioning products can help keep them supple and in good condition. If you prefer a lead with a comfortable grip and a more traditional look, leather might be the right choice.
Chain Leads
Chain leads are incredibly strong and durable, making them a good option for dogs that tend to chew their lead. However, they’re not always the most comfortable for the handler. If your dog pulls on the lead, the chain can be harsh on your hands, and the metallic rattling sound may spook some dogs. {erspma; ly I do NOT recommend these type
Retractable Leads
Retractable leads can be a divisive choice. On the one hand, they offer dogs greater freedom to explore while staying tethered, which can be particularly useful in parks or open spaces. However, they come with notable risks. Grabbing the cord of a retractable lead can cause injuries like burns or even fractured fingers, and some people feel these leads encourage pulling or less responsive behaviour to commands.
I do not like these leads; they are only good for attaching a lure for sighthounds. However, if you must use one, please ensure you get the one best suited for your dog’s weight and the type that is more like a ribbon rather than a cord.
Elastic Leads
Elastic leads are designed to absorb the shock of sudden pulls, which can reduce strain on both you and your dog. Like retractable leads, they give dogs more freedom to roam, but they’re not ideal for training as they make enforcing clear boundaries harder.
I’ve not had that much experience with these
Long lines
Long lines are much better than retractable leads for giving your dog more freedom while maintaining control and safety. They are handy for recall training, allowing your dog to explore and roam at a greater distance while still being connected to you. This helps build confidence in dogs learning to respond to commands or need more space to burn off energy. Long lines are ideal for open areas like fields or parks where off-lead walking isn’t possible or safe. They also work well for nervous or reactive dogs, providing them more space to move while keeping them securely managed. With the right technique, a long line can enhance your dog’s physical and mental stimulation while ensuring a positive and secure walking experience.
Collars vs Harnesses
While a collar and lead is the traditional setup for walking dogs, harnesses have grown in popularity and are now finally recognised by the Kennel Club. Choosing a collar and a harness often depends on your dog’s size, behaviour, and specific health concerns.
Benefits of Harnesses
Harnesses are generally considered more comfortable for dogs, especially those who tend to pull. Unlike collars, which can put pressure on a dog’s neck and potentially cause harm, harnesses distribute pressure more evenly across the dog’s chest and shoulders. This makes them a great option for small breeds, brachycephalic dogs (those with short noses), or dogs with delicate necks.
Harnesses are also a safer choice for car journeys. Many harnesses come with attachments that can secure your dog to a seatbelt, preventing them from moving around in the car or becoming a distraction.
Potential Downsides of Harnesses
For long-haired dogs, harnesses can sometimes cause fur matting or skin irritation if worn for extended periods, especially if the harness is not properly fitted. Some dogs may also find harnesses restrictive initially, so choosing one that fits snugly but doesn’t rub or chafe is essential.
Another consideration is that harnesses can unintentionally encourage pulling. Dogs may feel more secure and comfortable in a harness, which can make them less responsive to lead corrections. However, this can be managed with proper training or a no-pull harness.
No-Pull Harnesses
A no-pull harness can be a game-changer if your dog tends to pull on the lead. These harnesses are designed with a lead attachment point at the front, typically on the chest. When your dog pulls, the design gently redirects it toward you, discouraging the pulling behaviour without causing pain or discomfort.
No-pull harnesses are an excellent training tool for larger or more energetic dogs. However, like all equipment, they’re most effective when paired with consistent training and positive reinforcement.
Finding the Perfect Fit
Fit and comfort should always be a priority when choosing a lead or harness. Consider your dog’s size and strength when choosing a lead—thicker, sturdier leads are better for large or strong dogs, while lightweight options work well for smaller breeds.
Take your dog’s measurements and consult the manufacturer’s sizing guide for harnesses to ensure a fit. A well-fitted harness should be snug but not too tight, allowing you to slip two fingers between the harness and your dog’s body. If your dog or the harness rubs are uncomfortable, try adjusting the straps or exploring different styles.
Making the Right Choice for You and Your Dog
Ultimately, the best lead and harness for your dog will depend on your unique needs. Here are a few tips to help you make an informed decision:
- Consider your dog’s behaviour: A no-pull harness might be worth exploring if your dog is a puller. If your dog chews through leads, a chain lead could save you from frequent replacements.
- Think about your walking environment: A short lead offers better control in urban areas with lots of traffic, while retractable leads might be useful in open spaces.
- Prioritise comfort and safety: Look for equipment that minimises strain on your dog and reduces the risk of injury to you or your pet.
The Importance of Training
While the right lead and harness can make walks more enjoyable, training remains key to a positive walking experience. Teaching your dog to walk calmly on a loose lead and respond to basic commands will ensure every outing is a pleasure, regardless of your chosen equipment.
If you’re unsure which lead or harness is best for your dog, consult a professional dog trainer or vet for personalised advice.
Happy Walking!
Walking your dog is about more than just exercise—it’s a chance to bond, explore, and enjoy each other’s company. With the right lead and harness, you’ll be well-equipped to make every walk a happy and safe adventure for you and your dog.
Below are some related articles you may be interested in